Fans left 'screaming' as all three Married at First Sight experts leave the show at once - with many declaring they won't watch without them

All three Married at First Sight relationship experts are leaving the show at once - with viewers declaring they won’t watch the show without them.

In a shock move nobody was expecting, all three Married At First Sight experts have announced they won’t be returning for the upcoming season.

Fans have reacted in horror at the news, with many saying the hit dating show won’t be the same without them and they won’t watch as a result. One particularly passionate viewer even said she’d been left “screaming” at the revelation.

Pastor Cal, Doctor Pepper Schwartz and Doctor Pia Holec, who up until now had all guiding the couples through the MAFS United States process for many years, won’t be returning to their roles for the upcoming season 20.

Sociologist Dr Pepper has been on the show since its original 2014 debut. Pastor Cal was the show's marriage counsellor from 2016, while Dr Pia joined as an intimacy and relationship specialist in 2022. The new experts who will take their place haven't yet been announced.

All three have released statements on their decision to leave, and it seems they all now feel the time is right to focus on something different.

All three Married at First Sight United States experts are leaving the show. Photo by Married at First Sight.placeholder image
All three Married at First Sight United States experts are leaving the show. Photo by Married at First Sight. | Married at First Sight

Dr Pepper said: “I leave this post with gratitude and optimism, knowing that the foundation we’ve built will continue to evolve and inspire. I’m excited to move on to new projects, carrying with me the lessons, relationships, and memories from this incredible experience.”

Pastor Cal said: “Serving as the spiritual advisor and relationship coach on Married at First Sight has been one of the great honors of my life. I am passing the torch with love and faith, believing the work will continue to touch lives in powerful ways. This is not goodbye; it’s a new, exciting chapter. I’m elated about the doors God is already opening, and forever thankful for the seasons we shared.”

Dr Pia said: “I’m prioritizing time with my family while focusing on my clinical work and educational projects centered on mental health, interpersonal relationships, and intimacy.”

In a statement to Us Weekly, executive producer Chris Coelen said: “We’re thrilled to be embarking on a brand new chapter of the MAFS journey with our partners at Peacock. We’re excited for the future and honored to have worked alongside Dr. Pepper, Pastor Cal and Dr. Pia.

“Dr. Pepper has been with us from the beginning and Pastor Cal joined us shortly thereafter; their unwavering wisdom, insight and passion has been a guiding light for us throughout the seasons.”

Fans aren’t pleased that Dr Pepper, Pastor Cal and Dr Pia are all leaving. One person wrote online: “I saw this and Screamed!!!! OMG! I don’t even know if I could ever watch this show again after this it won’t be the same.” Another fan simply wished the three of them luck.

MAFS US season 20 will air later this year on Peacock, but a release date has not yet been announced. MAFS Australia season 12 will be airing in February in Aus and March in the UK. MAFS UK will also air series 11 later this year but a release date has also not yet been announced, however, the show typically airs in September.

Related topics:
Telling news your way
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice