Health Expert Calls for Change in School Shoe Policy to Protect Children’s Foot Health
A senior orthotist at Sheffield Children’s Hospital has launched a petition urging schools to modernise their uniform policies by allowing students to wear black trainers instead of traditional dress shoes.
Francesca Makey, who specialises in treating children with foot and mobility issues, says outdated footwear rules are harming children’s long-term health. She believes supportive, cushioned trainers offer better protection against discomfort, pain, and even future knee problems.
“Simply updating uniform rules to allow black trainers could help protect the health of thousands of children,” Makey said, adding that rigid dress shoes often don’t accommodate medical insoles or orthotic supports.
Although some primary schools already permit trainers, most secondary schools still require formal black shoes. Educators like Katie Crook, vice principal at Penistone Grammar School, argue that uniforms foster community identity, but admit the issue sparks frequent internal debate. Concerns were also raised about equity, with some worried that allowing expensive branded trainers could increase social pressure among students.
The call for change is supported by families like 14-year-old Amira’s. Born with a severe foot condition, Amira finds relief in her orthotic-friendly trainers, which allow her to attend school comfortably. “We’re already in uniform—we’re smart enough,” she said, encouraging schools to prioritise health over outdated traditions.