Slim boy fat: Mum's fury as school brands sporty boy 'overweight' in 'barbaric' school BMI test

JACK ATHERTON, FIVE, WHO HAS BEEN DEEMED OVERWEIGHT BY THE NHS CHILD MEASUREMENT PROGRAMMEplaceholder image
JACK ATHERTON, FIVE, WHO HAS BEEN DEEMED OVERWEIGHT BY THE NHS CHILD MEASUREMENT PROGRAMME

An angry mum has slammed the NHS for branding her 'sporty' five-year-old overweight - claiming school BMI tests are 'barbaric and dangerous'.

Laura Atherton had given permission for slim son Jack Atherton to take part in the National Child Measurement Programme at his primary school last month.

However, the 34-year-old laughed when she received a results letter from Halton Borough Council, Cheshire, Wednesday, May 21, declaring Jack as overweight.

The mum-of-two insists her 'sporty' son plays football once a week and has been going swimming since he was two months old. Angry Laura says Jack isn't chubby at all and blames the outdated BMI (body mass index) system for not understanding kids grow at different rates'.

JACK ATHERTON, FIVE, AND MUM LAURA ATHERTON, 34placeholder image
JACK ATHERTON, FIVE, AND MUM LAURA ATHERTON, 34

She says the system is 'dangerous' for impressionable parents, who could put their children on unnecessary diets and for children's confidence if they're told the results. Jack is 3ft 5in and weighs 3.5st, which puts him in the 97th percentile for his age and in the overweight bracket (91 and above).

Tech complaints manager Laura posted an explainer video to TikTok, including a picture of her regular-build son, and users were gobsmacked.

Laura, from Widnes, Cheshire, said: "I laughed when I saw it and said it's got to be a joke. Once it settled I thought classifying him as that was really bad. It's barbaric and horrendous.

"He's very active and he's always been active. He's been swimming since he was a couple of months old. He still goes swimming every week on a Saturday and he goes to football every Monday. He's a normal-build five-year-old and he's wearing age 4-5 clothes.

"It angers me because what more can we be doing? I don't think he's overweight and everyone we know is outraged. People might think I've got rose-tinted glasses on and maybe he's a bit chubby but she doesn't see it but he isn't chubby at all. There's nothing to him.

"If I fed him less he'd be hungry. He's a growing lad and that's obviously not something I'm going to do. From the checks online, I think if he was 3-4cm taller then he'd be in the healthy weight bracket, which is mental because they all grow at different rates at that age.

"When Jack came home last night and asked for a biscuit I wondered if he should, but why was I thinking that? It's impacted me as well, it's ridiculous.

"I don't want him to be overweight and that's a choice we make every day through his meals and making sure we get fruit and veg down him. Jack doesn't know about it and he won't know about it either, he doesn't need to."

Laura, who also lives with hubby Sam, 36, and their other son George, one, insists Jack's weight hasn't been brought up by medical professionals before.

The National Child Measurement Programme measures the height and weight of children in reception class (aged 4-5) and year six (aged 10-11) to assess overweight and obesity levels in primary school children.

The programme uses BMI for the programme, which is a measure of whether you're a healthy weight for your height, and includes a QR code on the results letter to advise parents.

Laura believes such tests should be done at clinics rather than schools but doesn't feel BMI is fit for purpose anyway. Laura said: "I'm not a doctor but I don't think BMI is fit for purpose. I think it's dangerous and outdated.

"Some parents are really impressionable and if they didn't feel as strongly as I did then their kids might be going on a diet unnecessarily.

"If you're a child and you're told you're overweight then that could have a real detrimental impact on their confidence and their relationship with food.

"I think it's a terrible idea to weigh kids in school. The next check is when they go into high school and that's such an impressionable age and they'll be talking about it.

"I agree with it in the correct environment for children that need help so I think these checks need to be through the doctors and school isn't the right setting. It's created a world of worry I didn't need."

Laura's TikTok video, captioned 'I'm fuming', has been viewed almost half a million times. One commented: I always refuse these, the only medical things I allow on school premises are vaccinations.

A second wrote: I am gobsmacked. He looks like a very healthy boy! I'm shocked that schools can do this. A third commented: As a nurse, I've always strongly disagreed with the BMI chart and its terminology.

It is SO outdated and it does not consider weight in line with height and muscle to fat ratio. I'm overweight according to it and I'm a size 8-10 and 5ft 10in! it needs to be scrapped completely! One wrote: No, I see what they are saying. it is important to monitor it from an early age.

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: "The National Childhood Measurement Programme (NCMP) is vital to inform action to improve the health of all children and promote a healthier weight.

"We recognise that weight and growth can be very sensitive for some children, and their wellbeing is our priority. The privacy and dignity of children must be safeguarded at all times, and no child is forced to take part.

"School nursing teams and NCMP delivery staff measure children in a sensitive way, in private and away from other children, with weight and height information shared only with the parent or carer in a feedback letter.

"This government is shifting focus from sickness to prevention under our 10 Year Health Plan to meet our ambition of raising the healthiest generation of children ever."

Related topics:
Telling news your way
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice