How can Keir Starmer survive as the British Prime Minister?

As Westminster gossips about odds, polls and looming local elections, strategy advisor Steve McCauley argues that Keir Starmer’s fate will turn less on party intrigue than on whether he can reframe the national story around security, Europe and leadership in an era of Russian hybrid warfare, American unreliability and a fractured British right.
The consensus among the political commentariat is virtually unanimous: the Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, will probably face a leadership challenge in the coming months. William Hill has the odds of Starmer not being in post by the end of 2026 at 60 percent. The far-right Reform UK party has a 54.5 percent chance of winning the next election. Labour trails at 26.7%. Local elections loom ominously in May 2026.
It all looked different on July 4, 2024. Labour won the General Election in a landslide. It currently has a majority of 148 seats. The country was desperate for change after 14 years of misrule by feral Conservatives who inflicted Brexit chaos, failed to deliver growth and mismanaged the Covid-19 emergency (apart from fast-tracking vaccines).
Boris Johnson lied to the Commons when Prime Minister in 2020: Partygate. His successor, Liz Truss, lasted 44 days before being forced to resign in October 2022. Her lunatic mini-budget included billions of pounds of unfunded tax cuts. This spooked the bond markets, crashed the pound and sent interest rates into orbit. Only swift action by the Bank of England prevented a disaster.

The sense of relief that the scoundrels had been banished was palpable. Yet within days of assuming office, Starmer’s government looked seasick. The first sign of trouble was a self-inflicted scandal involving gifts that the PM had accepted, including designer suits, glasses and tickets to see Taylor Swift. It then emerged that the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, had accepted thousands of pounds worth of clothes to smarten up her act. It made them look as bad as the Tories.
From the first minute, the mood music from the new government was gloom and doom. There was a “£22bn black hole” in the public finances. Having promised not to raise taxes on "working people”, whatever that means, the Chancellor withdrew winter fuel allowances from pensioners and reduced benefits for disabled people. Despite his huge majority, Starmer was forced to retreat by the Labour left. Reeves resorted to increasing taxes on businesses, reducing their willingness to hire more people. The Autumn 2025 budget turned into a fiasco. Reeves was accused of misleading the country about how much fiscal headroom she had. Taxes rose again, in spite of promises in 2024 that this would not happen.
Critics of Keir Starmer portray him as a weak leader: a man devoid of charisma, a poor communicator, who vacillates and who lacks vision. From the moment he stepped into Downing Street, he faced a chorus of negativity from right-wing media. Reform UK has benefitted from the partisan support of GB News with its leader, Nigel Farage, as a presenter. The billionaire investors behind GB News seem to think that the £100 million it had lost by February 2025 is a small price to get their man into No 10.
Starmer came into office in the gaze of unforgiving social media coverage. He has faced a personal onslaught from Elon Musk, owner of Twitter/X. Musk has supported the far-right AfD party in Germany. Much of the negative commentary about Starmer and Labour is disinformation from malicious state actors, but that does not stop credulous social media users from believing it.
And yet, and yet: all is not lost for Keir Starmer. He is widely acknowledged to have been effective in international matters, in spite of daunting challenges. He came to office two years after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. He redoubled the UK’s unwavering support for Ukraine and Starmer sought to undo the vandalism that Boris Johnson caused to relations with the EU.
Now, a year after Donald Trump re-entered the White House, the world has changed. America can no longer be relied upon as an ally. Trump is aligned with Putin and has threatened to invade Greenland. In navigating this madness, Starmer has shown diplomatic skill. He managed to minimise the damage caused by Trump’s tariffs. The UK pulled out all the stops for a state visit by Trump in September. It was nauseating but effective, at least momentarily.
The reality is that there are three and a half years before the next General Election must be held and anything could happen. There is a dawning understanding in the UK and Europe that we are already in a state of war with Russia; not a cold war, but an almost-war, the so-called grey zone. Russia is engaged in hybrid warfare against European nations, using cyberattacks, sabotage, political subversion, espionage, assassination, information warfare and more. The fact is that Europe foolishly let itself rely on the United States for its security, only to find that America cannot be trusted. The public will become more aware of the seriousness of this dilemma over the coming year, and it will demand and expect serious leadership.
Against this background, Keir Starmer has the obligation and the opportunity to lead and place the UK again at the heart of European affairs. In contrast, Nigel Farage has a problem. He has for a long time been seen as a Putin admirer, a sceptic of Nato and as an apologist for Russia, as well as a Trump groupie. Nathan Gill, the former Leader of Reform UK in Wales and an MEP until January 2020, was jailed in September 2025 for ten and a half years for taking bribes from a pro-Russian Ukrainian businessman, to promote Russian interests. How many other traitors are there?
Keir Starmer has identified the main political threat as coming from Reform UK. Polls show Reform UK ahead at 33 per cent, versus Labour on 18. It had been thought that Reform and the Conservatives might reach some kind of pact, but dozens of current and former Tory MPs have defected to Reform. The Conservative Leader has ruled out a deal and declared that the party will also move towards the far right, leaving centrist Conservatives homeless. The upshot is that this knife fight on the right of British politics might well split the right-wing vote, to Labour’s benefit.
Labour MPs and supporters would do well to remember that divided parties lose. The British public became sick of the Conservatives when they indulged in infighting and had five Prime Ministers between 2016 and 2024.
If he is to win, now is the time for Keir Starmer to add to his game in a number of critical respects. The “doom and gloom” narrative must be replaced by one which sets out a number of crucial arguments. He needs to level with the British people about that state we’re in and describe a clear and compelling story about the country we should become. We need to understand what the government - and the country - is trying to achieve and why it matters: what is at stake, what we need to get done and what sacrifices we might have to make to get there. We need to be reminded of the values that we hold dear and the principles which we will not compromise, which will always guide our actions.
We need to understand the role we are being asked to play. England expects, and all that. The Prime Minister needs to express a sense of hope and optimism that we can achieve this, which of course we can, as the UK is a great country which has overcome challenges and hardships; a country that has defeated tyrants in the darkest hour. He also needs to convey a sense of expectation: what is required of each and every one of us.
In doing so, the Prime Minister can lay the foundations to explain the priorities and plans of the government and the country that will resonate with voters. He will be able to convince people about why we need to secure much closer ties with Europe. He needs to spell out the fundamental damage caused to our economy (Brexit has reduced UK GDP by 6% to 8%, according to The Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, November 2025) and find ways to fix it without further delay - as a matter of national security, because of the threat from Russia.
Nigel Farage was one of the main drivers of Brexit and this disaster needs to be tattooed across his forehead. There is no longer any gain for Labour in pretending that you can “Make Brexit work”. It’s like saying “Make the Sun rise in the West and set in the East”. Labour has already lost the pro-Brexit “Red Wall" voters to Reform UK. It can retain and attract pro-European supporters. It doesn’t have to mean re-joining the EU and allowing free movement of people. Indeed, Labour is already on track to reduce immigration dramatically, due to the changes introduced by the Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, which undermines Reform UK’s main appeal.
Above all, Keir Starmer should show people more of what he’s like as a human being. In person, he can be relaxed, great company and has a good sense of humour, but you’d never know it from the robotic, dreary, semi-scripted television appearances and speeches he gives. Loosen up a little. There’s a lot to learn by observing how well this kind of thing is done by Zohran Mamdani, the likeable new Mayor of New York City.
Is it far-fetched that Keir Starmer can survive as British Prime Minister, see off his rivals and win the next election? No, it is not, provided he makes some changes, if he leads from the front with the right tone, if the right of British politics eats itself, if the ball bounces in his favour and if the Labour Party holds its nerve.
Steve McCauley is a leadership coach, strategic advisor and journalist whose career spans media, government, digital technology and international development. A Senior Fellow of the Centre for Resilience and Sustainable Development, University of Cambridge and a certified executive coach, he has advised presidents, ministers, CEOs and global organisations on strategy, governance and creative thinking in complex environments.
Belters News