New art shows what Tolkien characters should look like amid The Rings of Power portrayal controversy
As the second season of Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power approaches, anticipation is mixed with trepidation.
The first season of the Amazon Prime series, released in September 2022 and set in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth, faced significant backlash from fans disappointed with the portrayal of iconic characters, as mostly the elves don't look like what people had typically imagined.
In response, experts at KingCasinoBonus used A.I. to generate portrayals of these characters faithful to Tolkien’s original descriptions.
Despite its vast budget, the show faced a torrent of criticism, reflected in a Metacritic user score of 2.9 from nearly 3,000 reviews, and a Rotten Tomatoes audience score of just 38% from over 1,000 viewers. Fan reviewers called it "an insult to Tolkien's heritage" and slammed the writing as "God awful."
- Galadriel
Tolkien describes the Lady of Lórien, portrayed in the series by Morfydd Clark, as “the mightiest and fairest of all the Elves that remained in Middle-earth." She was tall, with long silver-gold hair that cascaded down her shoulders and piercing eyes that glowed with the light of the Two Trees of Valinor, as she was one of the last beings to see them. This description seems to fit a lot better with Cate Blanchett’s portrayal of the character in the Lord of The Rings movies, which fans are still greatly fond of.
- Elrond
Elrond is one of the characters best described in the books, playing a part both in the Lord of the Rings storyline and in the Hobbit. He “seemed ageless, resembling neither old nor young. However, one could see in his face the memories and experiences of thousands of years. He looked venerable like an old king, a wise wizard, and an experienced warrior in his prime.” Moreover, he is described as “dark-haired, while his eyes were grey, shining like starlight.” Lastly, he wore a circlet of silver.
- Tom Bombadil
Probably one of the most enigmatic characters of the whole series, Tom Bombadil was never shown in the original LOTR trilogy, leaving the adapters of The Rings of Power with a bit more freedom. Like Elrond, Bombadil is meticulously described “like an old man who was taller and heavier than a Hobbit, but not quite tall enough for a man. His face was creased and red as a ripe apple with blue and bright eyes. His hands were brown-skinned. He had thick brown hair and a long brown beard.” Moreover, Tom wore a blue coat and an old tall hat with a long blue feather and yellow boots.
- Sauron
The villain, who we never see in his bodily form except for a flashback, is set to appear in the next season. While Sauron’s description is not as accurate as other characters, we know that he was a shapeshifter who got stuck in a monstrous form after turning evil. Before that, he had appeared as a royal and commanding figure with a strong body. He was a Maia, a supernatural and angelic being who could incarnate in men's bodies on Middle Earth. Moreover, he was a blacksmith, originally following Aulë the smith, one of the Valar. He hated disorder, so his appearance was well put together, yet his features were hard.
A spokesperson for KingCasinoBonus commented: “Expanding an already beloved universe is always a risk, but with the world created by Tolkien, one might expect that it would be easier than most, as the professor was incredibly meticulous and exhaustive with most of its content, including character descriptions.
“This might be one of the reasons why fans lamented a wide range of aspects of the series, from the perceived lack of authenticity in the sets and costumes to the decision to give elves short, contemporary-looking hair and poorly crafted armor.
“The adaptation has been under fire since the release of the first season, and given the heavy criticism, despite the new season approaching, this is unlikely to change anytime soon.”