Dad’s £2,763 ScS sofa nightmare as new settee branded ‘10 years old’ after delivery

Stephen Partridge says 11 months of complaints have left him and his wife facing a furniture nightmare, with an independent report highlighting multiple alleged faults. But ScS disputes the findings.

A house-proud dad has been locked in an 11-month battle with furniture giant ScS after claiming a nearly £3,000 sofa set arrived looking like it had already endured a decade of use.

Stephen Partridge, who is locked in a dispute with SCS sofas after finding a number of issues with his brand-new suite delivery. placeholder image
Stephen Partridge, who is locked in a dispute with SCS sofas after finding a number of issues with his brand-new suite delivery. | Charley Atkins / SWNS

Stephen Partridge, 58, and wife Cheryl, 52, splashed out £2,763 on a stylish dark grey reclining sofa set in December 2025, hoping to make their living room more comfortable. But the couple say their dream purchase quickly turned into a nightmare after discovering one settee was a different colour and another had visible damage.

The couple purchased the Bagnolo reclining sofa collection from ScS in Rotherham in December 2025.placeholder image
The couple purchased the Bagnolo reclining sofa collection from ScS in Rotherham in December 2025. | Charley Atkins / SWNS

The Bagnolo collection, bought from ScS in Parkgate, Rotherham, included a three-seater, two-seater and matching footstool, complete with power recliners. The furniture was delivered in April 2026, but Stephen soon noticed the two-seater was a noticeably lighter shade of grey. Their daughter Stephanie, 30, also spotted the mismatch, while the three-seater allegedly had two large indentations on its armrest.

Stephen complained and the incorrectly coloured sofa was eventually replaced. However, he claims the replacement, delivered in August, was in even worse condition, with missing padding, a damaged appearance and fabric that looked "10 years old".

Determined to get answers, Stephen commissioned an independent furniture inspection in September, paying £264 for a report.The assessment identified several alleged problems, including insufficient padding in a headrest, a black mark embedded in the fabric, a 10.5cm indentation and excess material causing unsightly wrinkles. It also raised concerns about the fabric around both reclining mechanisms, concluding that a repair would not provide a satisfactory solution.

ScS disputes the independent report and maintains its own inspection found no manufacturing defects.placeholder image
ScS disputes the independent report and maintains its own inspection found no manufacturing defects. | Charley Atkins / SWNS

Stephen, who works as a full-time carer for Cheryl, said the purchase was meant to improve life for his wife, who has multiple sclerosis. He said: "What was supposed to be a positive experience has turned into a nightmare."

But ScS, owned by Italian retailer Poltronesofà, strongly disputes the findings. A spokesperson said an independent technician appointed by the company found no manufacturing faults or defects.

They added that regular plumping and dressing of the upholstery would address the concerns and advised the couple to approach the Furniture and Home Improvement Ombudsman if they remained unhappy.

Telling news your way
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice