One Tree Hill actress Bethany Joy Lenz was left 'weeping on the floor' after being in a cult for a decade

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission on items purchased through this article, but that does not affect our editorial judgement.

In the early noughties Bethany Joy Lenz had a leading role in one of the most popular television series’ of the time, One Tree Hill, but she was also part of a cult.

At the same time as the TV star’s career was flourishing, she was also deeply devoted to a small, ultra-Christian group led by a disreputable pastor who controlled her career, life choices and even her bank account.

It took her a decade to get out and by the time she did she was a divorced mum-of-one and she had hardly anything to show for the nearly nine years she spent on the series. She also felt regret and shame for not realising sooner that she had been lied to and taken advantage of.

The now 43-year-old actress, who was in her early 20s at the time, has told the full truth about the situation in her new memoir Dinner for Vampires Life on a Cult TV Show (While also in an Actual Cult!). The book is released on Tuesday (October 22), but can be pre-ordered on Amazon now.

Lenz says she first met the pastor through a bible study group she'd joined when she moved to Los Angeles at the age 20 to further her acting career. At first, she loved the group, they'd sing, worship and have philosophical conversations about God and life's meaning. She said that the group felt like "water in a desert" as she had never before had that kind of connection with other people before.

When a visiting pastor she calls "Les" began to come to the study nights and lead the conversations, she didn't think there was anything strange about it — even when he convinced other members of the group to move to a "big house" in Idaho to live in a small, commune-like environment. She says: "It still looked normal. And then it just morphed. But by the time it started morphing, I was too far into the relationships to notice.” She adds: "Plus, I was so young."

One Tree Hill actress Bethany Joy Lenz has opened up about being in a cult when she was on the TV show. Photo by Getty Images.placeholder image
One Tree Hill actress Bethany Joy Lenz has opened up about being in a cult when she was on the TV show. Photo by Getty Images. | Getty Images

She says Les eventually persuaded her to move to the house. Once she moved in, she claims he controlled many areas of her life including her finances. Speaking about it, she says: "I don't know if I like the term brainwashing. I think it's more… high control."

She adds: "For 10 years, I lived in this bubble of 'Unless you believe in the same God that I believe in, unless you believe in having relationships the same way that I believe [in], unless you do all the things on the same checklist that I'm doing, I can't learn from you. You can't teach me anything'… What a terrible mistake."

The Haley James/Scott actress said her One Tree Hill co-stars expressed their concerns as they could see she was in a cult, but she didn’t want to admit it at the time. "I could see it on their faces. But I'd justify it, like 'I couldn't possibly be in a cult. It's just that I've got access to a relationship with God and people in a way that everybody else wants, but they don't know how to get it’," she explains.

She married a fellow “family member” in 2005 and gave birth to their daughter Rosie in 2011. But, a year after her daughter’s birth she realised she wanted out of the marriage and the cult. "The stakes were so high," she says. "They were my only friends. I was married into this group. I had built my entire life around it. If I admitted that I was wrong ... everything else would come crumbling down."

She went on: “"I had many, many weeping on the floor nights, just trying to figure out how to manage and what I was going to do. And what to do with my emotions: the anger, the injustice.

Lenz says she's still recovering from her time in the cult, 12 years after she got out. She says she’s still healing. "There's no quick way through. But I don't know that that's the point. I don't think that's the point after experiencing trauma or suffering is to just [be] like, ‘OK, how do I get over this?’"

"I'm still healing. It's just day by day. Person by person. Interaction by interaction. Making the choice to trust someone that you're not sure if you can trust, finding out you were right, shouldn't have trusted them. Finding out you were wrong, and that little thing that you were like, ‘I don’t know if I can trust,' maybe was just fear because of everything that's happened."

She also says that she hasn’t written her memoir with any negative intent. "I didn't write this book to get revenge on anyone. I just wanted to tell an honest truth about what happened." Lenz also believes she will help people "who have experienced this and don't know what to do with their shame. Who may be currently experiencing it and don't quite know how to identify what they're feeling, but maybe they can recognize and see something in what I'm saying.” She adds that she wants to “help people who might otherwise get into something like this [so] now they know what red flags to look for."

Related topics:
Telling news your way
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice