Mum-of-five fined £11k after accidentally throwing AA batteries in incorrect bin
A mum-of-five said she "broke down" after being told she owed £11,000 for throwing batteries in the incorrect bin.
A mum-of-five has been fined more than £11,000 after accidentally throwing AA batteries in the incorrect bin - as they were inside children's toys. The toys were thrown out as Krystal Ogier and her family moved out of their home after 10 years and hired a private refuse firm.
By mistake, the 33-year-old included four toys that contained 23 batteries in the heavy collection - with the company, Island Waste, later fining her £500 per battery - a total of £11,500. Krystal said she "broke down" when she received the news and had simply not realised the batteries were inside the toys.
The hairdresser said: "I just broke down. I just thought there was no way I could pay this fine and that I was going to do jail time. I have never been in trouble for anything before. Having a fine like that hanging over your head, there was just no way I could pay for it.
"I like all my debts to be clear, especially nowadays everyone is struggling how is anyone able to afford those penalty charges? It was a genuine mistake."
Island Waste agreed to reduce the fine to £1,000, but Krystal said the cost would still have an impact. Krystal, from Guernsey, said she understands it is her fault and that it was "irresponsible".


"It was my fault, how could I be so stupid to not even think there was AA batteries in those toys," she said. "You just chuck things into the bag without thinking about it. I get it, it’s a hazard. I do understand why there is penalty charges."
The mum-of-five said she understood why Island Waste had its fine system but felt the rates were "extortionate". "I just think the penalty charges are a bit extortionate," she said. "I think they could make it clearer to people. There should be something in red writing on their website that says something about the fines."
She is now hoping to raise awareness and inform people that these fines can happen. "When you are getting rid of things maybe don't be irresponsible like me," she went on. "I was just chucking things in the bag. People need to be aware of this charges and know how much they cost."
According to the Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS), batteries and electrical products "can leak toxic chemicals into the environment if they end up in a landfill site", and may even cause fires.
Faye Grime, Island Waste's director, said the firm had a "bold red banner" online highlighting the safe disposal of batteries and a box customers must tick to declare they had checked items. Ms Grime said Krystal had checked the box and accepted the company’s waste criteria, which outlines the penalty fee.
She said: "We do not want to issue fines, we want our customers to please respect and adhere to our waste acceptance criteria which is issued on safety and compliance grounds. However, a fine is set to highlight and reflect the danger and consequences of leaving batteries in mixed waste, and the danger it presents to people, property and the environment."
She added: "The consequences of a battery fire can be catastrophic for a waste site, rapidly spreading and causing risk of injury to people, damage to property and the environment. Once batteries begin their processing journey, the risk of the battery’s integrity being compromised increases dramatically, and with it the risk of fire and/or toxic release."
