Tax rises ‘likely’ as Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt plot to fill £40bn black hole in UK finances, Treasury warns

A source for the Treasury said “everybody will need to contribute” more tax to fill the nation’s financial black hole

People across the UK could face tax rises for years to come as Rishi Sunak seeks to fill a £40 billion ‘black hole’  in the public finances, reports suggest.

The Prime Minister and Chancellor Jeremy Hunt met on Monday to discuss options for the financial statement on 17 November and agreed “tough decisions” were needed on both tax rises and spending.

Sunak and Hunt agreed to freeze the thresholds at which people start to pay the different rates of income tax and national insurance, according to the Daily Telegraph.

Hunt is reportedly looking to fill the shortfall through a combination of 50% tax rises and 50% public spending cuts in his Autumn Statement and a Treasury source has warned “everybody would need to contribute more in tax in the years ahead”.

The paper quotes the source as saying: “It is going to be rough. The truth is that everybody will need to contribute more in tax if we are to maintain public services. After borrowing hundreds of billions of pounds through Covid-19 and implementing massive energy bills support, we won’t be able to fill the fiscal black hole through spending cuts alone.”

Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt met on Monday to discuss options for the financial statement on 17 November (Photo: PA)Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt met on Monday to discuss options for the financial statement on 17 November (Photo: PA)
Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt met on Monday to discuss options for the financial statement on 17 November (Photo: PA)

The warning came as a Resolution Foundation report said Sunak and Hunt face an “unpalatable menu” when it comes to rebalancing the nation’s finances. The report suggests at least £40 billion will need to be found by the government - most likely through a combination of tax rises and spending cuts - on the backdrop of a gloomy economic outlook thanks to the fallout from Liz Truss’s disastrous mini-budget.

The think tank said the Office for Budget Responsibility could predict a recession next year, with GDP forecasts cut by up to 4% by the end of 2024. Unemployment could also rise by around half a million, the report suggests, with the weaker economic outlook bringing borrowing up by around £20 billion a year by 2026-2027.

James Smith, research director at the Resolution Foundation, said: “The government has a little over two weeks to finalise its plans to repair its economic credibility and the sustainability of the public finances.

“While the recent focus has been on conditions improving post-Trussonomics, the central picture remains one of a weaker growth, higher borrowing costs and expensive tax cuts that have left a fiscal hole of at least £40 billion to fill.”

The government may struggle to meet its fiscal rules of reducing the debt-to-GDP ratio in the medium term and deliver a current-budget balance unless “significant further policy action is taken”, according to the report.

‘Austerity for public services likely’

Among the “menu” of options open to the Chancellor are cuts to investment spending, a move the Resolution Foundation said could save £10 billion but also have a detrimental impact on growth.

The think tank also suggests the government could try to choose the so-called “austerity option”, but such a move would require cuts to already-squeezed department budgets.

The think tank said: “With inflation at its highest level for 40 years, government departments are already seeing their budgets fall in real terms by around £22 billion by 2024-25. It is hard to see how the Treasury could credibly save more than £20 billion by announcing cuts to day-to-day public service spending.”

The Resolution Foundation study suggests the new administration could save £9 billion by choosing not to raise benefits and pensions in line with rising prices next year, adding that any such move would have a “huge” impact on those struggling, with a low-income working family with two children losing around £750 and a pensioner £342.

One option open to Sunak and Hunt would be to “go full circle” on the mini-budget by reinstating the health and social care levy – a move that would raise £15 billion by 2026-27. Around £2 billion could also be raised by extending the “stealth” freezes in income tax thresholds by a further year to 2026-27.

Mr Smith said the lesson from history is public investment projects are likely to face cuts. He explained: “History tells us that this will involve cuts to public investment, which are easy to announce but reduce growth in the longer term.

“Further austerity for public services is also likely, but there are limits to how big these can credibly be, as public services are already facing cuts of £22 billion thanks to high inflation. This reality means that the Autumn Statement is likely to involve tax rises, not just spending cuts.”