Shockingly, of the 19 men and women who have carried out their search for a relationship by signing up to at least two dating shows - 17 of them have married a stranger on Married at First Sight. There’s also a three contestants who have applied the saying ‘third time is the charm’ by trying their luck on not one, not two dating shows, but three.
Many contestants have appeared on other hugely popular dating shows which are on our screens now, such as First Dates, along with the second dating show to be created by the MAFS producers, Love Triangle.
For others, it’s forgotten shows which are no longer being made which marked their first attempt at reality TV love, from Take Me Out, to Don’t Tell The Bride, Dress to Impress and Dinner Date.
This seems to confirm what we have long suspected: While there are application forms that anyone can fill in to be in with a chance at being on our beloved dating shows - and I know that’s true because I was almost on First Dates - some contestants are put forward for the shows from their talent agencies or scouted by the producers themselves. How else could it be explained that these 19 people have been selected to appear on more than one dating show when each one gets thousands of applicants?
So, take a look through our gallery and see which dating show hopefuls you recognise.
Read more:
- 17 Married at First Sight couples from Aus, UK, US and NZ who have babies - plus two MAFS stars who are pregnant now
- Married at First Sight Australia: 8 most shocking moments from the show's most controversial brides and grooms
- Do Married at First Sight couples get married? Find out if MAFS UK, Australia, United States, and New Zealand weddings are legally binding
- 48 couples who met on UK and US dating TV shows and are still together - from Love Island to First Dates

5. Georges Berthonneau
Speaking of Georges Berthonneau, he also had a brush with reality TV fame before going on MAFS. In 2018 he appeared on Celebs Go Dating. Back then, he was one of the everyday people who was paired up with a celeb in the hope of sparking romance. He was coupled up with ‘The Only Way is Essex’ star Chloe Sims. The couple went on three dates, but didn’t pursue a relationship. Photos by Channel 4. | Channel 4

6. Danika Fenty
Danika Fenty first appeared on ITV dating show Love Bites, in 2021. The show, which had two seasons from 2020 to 2012, was hosted by Scarlett Moffatt and saw singletons cook a three course meal in the hope of impressing a potential date - all without a recipe. Danika chose between three men who had cooked for her, and though she got on with the person she ultimately chose for a date it obviously didn't go anywhere. In 2024, she was a picker once again on E4 dating show Love Triangle UK. The premise saw pickers choose between just two handpicked partners - but they only get to know them on text and don't know what their suitors look like until a choice is made and a blind date happens. Eventually, all three move in together to test whether connections are strongest if they are physical or emotional. Danika caused a stir by rejecting both of her suitors in favour of a fellow picker, Lloyd - but he ultimately rejected her. Photos by ITV/Channel 4. | ITV/Channel 4

7. Jack Gilkes
Jack Gilkes was another person who took part in Love Triangle last year. But, he was one of the suitors not the picker. His picker was a woman called Jasmine, who at first chose another prospective match, Matt, over him. However, when Jack then moved in he turned Jasmine's head and she chose to be with him. They stayed together for a short while outside of the show, but then they broke up. Prior to that, Gilkes was on two other ITV dating shows. In 2021, he was also on Love Bites. He was given the chance to cook for two potential dates, but on each occasion he failed to win the date. Then, in 2022, he appeared on The Cabins, which saw singletons move in to a log cabin together in the hopes of sparking up romance. He did not find love. Photo by ITV/Channel 4. | ITV/Channel 4

8. Paige and Lacey Martin
Olay, so this one is a bit of a cheat. Identical twins Paige and Lacey Martin (left and right) respectively have both been on dating shows. Paige was the first to look for love on reality TV on ITV's Dress To Impress, which had three seasons between 2017 and 2020 and asked singles to pick their dates based on outfits chosen for them by three potential suitors - and they have no idea what they look like. Paige was first seen choosing outfits for a man in 2019, but she wasn't chosen. The following year she was brought back, but this time she was the one asking for outfits and doing the choosing. The contestants bring family members and friends with them to help them decide which outfits are best and which outfits to choose. This is when viewers were first introduced to Lacey, who was there to support her twin. Then, in 2024, Lacey joined the cast of MAFS UK in her own search for love. She was paired with Nathan Campbell, and though the pair were loved up throughout the experiment and stayed together in the real world for some time, they split up after a few months together. Paige also failed to find love on Dress to Impress. Photos by ITV/Channel 4. | ITV/Channel 4


