Shockingly, of the 19 men and women who have carried out their search for a relationship by signing up to at least two dating shows - 17 of them have married a stranger on Married at First Sight. There’s also a three contestants who have applied the saying ‘third time is the charm’ by trying their luck on not one, not two dating shows, but three.
Many contestants have appeared on other hugely popular dating shows which are on our screens now, such as First Dates, along with the second dating show to be created by the MAFS producers, Love Triangle.
For others, it’s forgotten shows which are no longer being made which marked their first attempt at reality TV love, from Take Me Out, to Don’t Tell The Bride, Dress to Impress and Dinner Date.
This seems to confirm what we have long suspected: While there are application forms that anyone can fill in to be in with a chance at being on our beloved dating shows - and I know that’s true because I was almost on First Dates - some contestants are put forward for the shows from their talent agencies or scouted by the producers themselves. How else could it be explained that these 19 people have been selected to appear on more than one dating show when each one gets thousands of applicants?
So, take a look through our gallery and see which dating show hopefuls you recognise.
Read more:
- 17 Married at First Sight couples from Aus, UK, US and NZ who have babies - plus two MAFS stars who are pregnant now
- Married at First Sight Australia: 8 most shocking moments from the show's most controversial brides and grooms
- Do Married at First Sight couples get married? Find out if MAFS UK, Australia, United States, and New Zealand weddings are legally binding
- 48 couples who met on UK and US dating TV shows and are still together - from Love Island to First Dates

13. Laura Vaughan
Laura Vaughan is another MAFS contestant who has hoped for a celebrity love connection on Celebs Go Dating previously. In 2022, she enjoyed a number of dates with actor Gary Lucy, but the following year she married Arthur Poremba on MAFS UK. The pair had many ups and downs during their relationship, although they did make it to final vows, where couples decide if they will stay together outside of the experiment. This is when Laura dumped Arthur. Photos by Channel 4. | Channel 4

14. Layton Mills
Layton Mills looked for love during season 10 of MAFS Australia in 2023. He was paired with Melinda Willis, and though they faced many challenges the couple actually made it to the end of the experiment and decided to be a couple in the real world. They were together for a year before they split. Prior to this, he appeared on the Australian version of First Dates. He was matched with a woman called Lani and the pair got on well. He later said they had seen each other four times after their TV date, but the romance didn't go anywhere. Photos by Channel Nine. | Channel Nine

15. April Banbury
April Banbury had already appeared on two reality TV shows before she tied the knot with George Roberts on MAFS UK in 2022. She took part in ITV's The Cabins in 2021. Ten years prior to that, in 2011, she appeared in Channel 5's The Bachelor, where she was one of 25 women hoping to win the heart of rugby player Gavin Henson. April came in third place on the show but ultimately went home single. April and George did leave the MAFS experiment as a couple but confirmed they had split up at the reunion, which was filmed a few weeks after the show ended. Photos by Channel 5/ITV/Channel 4. | Channel 5/ITV/Channel 4

16. Matt Murray
Another slight cheat here . . . Matt Murray found himself at the centre of the drama on series 7 of MAFS in 2022, as he decided to pursue a romance with fellow contestant Whitney Hughes - who was not the bride he'd been paired with, but she also chose to be with him over her husband. Before he appeared on MAFS, Matt was briefly seen on Channel 4's Naked Attraction. He didn't actually get naked, however, as he wasn't a contestant. One of his friends was and Matt was seen on the show talking about that friend. In an interesting twist of fate, Matt did also go on to date another MAFS bride, Marilyse Corrigan, who we know from earlier in this gallery also appeared on another reality dating show to support a pal. Matt and Marilyse also split after a six month romance. Photos by Channel 4. | Channel 4


